Last week, EU member states reached a compromise to allow the cultivation of genetically modified (GM) food crops. The compromise give the member states the rights to refuse GM corps on their territories, even if they have got clearance on health and safety grounds at EU level.
Under the proposal, member states who disagree with GM cultivation have to ask the Commission to ask companies to exclude them from requests for authorization for new crops, rather than directly approaching the companies.
A spokesman for Greece, holder of the rotating EU presidency, which put forward the compromise text, said the requirement that a member state has to make a request via the Commission would ensure maximum legal certainty, while still giving countries the right to refuse GM cultivation.
EU reaches compromise deal on genetically modified crops
After years of fractious talks, EU states have finally reached a compromise to allow cultivation of genetically modified (GM) food crops by giving their opponents an opt out, official sources said Wednesday. European Union member states will have the right to refuse GM crops on their territory, even if they have got clearance on health and safety grounds at the EU level, the sources said.
Reassured on this count, France, which has led the campaign against GM foods, plus Britain and Germany had dropped their opposition to the agreement, they said. In principle, EU approval should mean that all member states have no further say in the matter but in the face of intense opposition from France, other states and environmentalists, companies seeking GM approvals have been stalled for years in Brussels.
As a result, US agro-chemical giant Monsanto abandoned efforts to get new approvals last year, saying it was no longer worth the effort. Officials said the compromise means that when a company now applies for GM clearance, a member country can cite objections other than health and safety, such as concern over its impact on the environment or law and order issues, so as to be excluded from the EU approval.
“The compromise in the end offers more guarantees to the anti-GM countries,” one EU diplomat said. This arrangement will also offer “a fairly solid legal guarantee” against possible future court action by a company seeking to grow its GM crops in the EU, the diplomat said. Non-GM member states will however have to allow the transit of GM products through their territory.
Cultivation of GM foods stokes widespread suspicion in the 28-nation EU on health and environmental grounds. GM crops, however, have won repeated safety approvals and are imported into the EU in large amounts for animal feed. Several GM crops have won EU approval but only Monsanto’s MON810 maize is still grown after it was first cleared in 1998, with two other corn types plus BASF’s Amflora potato abandoned. The compromise agreement will go to environment ministers for approval on June 12. (AFP via brecoder.com)
However, according to some Greek media, the individual member-states ban is flimsy as it is not based on grounds of public health or the environment. The ban will apply only for reasons of public order and the cleaning of land to be cultivated.
“The reasons for each member-state to ban or allow the GM crops are not objective for the public health protection and/or the environment and therefore GM-crops producers may apply to the court and force a state to accept GM cultivation. Furthermore, no EU state can ban GM crops pass through its territory.
The agreement on GM bears the signature of deputy PM Venizelos and Environment Minister Maniatis.”
As I am highly allergic to corn tassels, my eyes are itching, my throat is sore and my lungs have spasms while writing this post and uploading the picture. 🙁
PS Quiz: will debt-ridden Greece allow cultivation of GM on its soil?
of course it’s crops’ and not …’corps’. another word I always misspell lol