Greek Privatisations: How to Shoot Your Own Foot or How Greece Lost $120 Million

Remember the recent sale of four Airbus A340-300 airplanes? The four four-engined airplanes once belonging to former state Olympic Airways finally got the signature of the Greek Finance Minister Yiannis Stournaras and were sold for the total price of 40.3 million dollars to Apollo Aviation Group in Miami for … scrap. 

However in 2007, when OA was closed down and  the four Air-Bus were estimated to have a worth of 45 million dollars each. Beginning of July, the four were sold for a total of $40 million.  About the absurdity of the delays with a loss of 120 million dollar, below is an article by the Economist:

The parable of the four-engined planes

AN OLD friend in the aviation business, with years of experience with Greek clients, told me a story that serves as a parable for how the country got into its current state. It concerns the sale of four Airbus long-haul planes after the national flag carrier, Olympic Airways, went bust. In 2007 an American valuation consultancy, Avitas, put a value of $45m on each of the A340-300 planes, which were then eight years old and still airworthy. Offers by outside firms to handle the sale were turned down. Instead a special state-owned firm with hundreds of employees was established, just to flog the four surplus planes.

In 2010 a small German airline called Cirrus offered $23m each for them. But the Greeks rejected this because of a rule that state assets could not be sold for less than 75% of their declared value. They then called for another expert valuation on the planes, which by then had been grounded for a year: the valuers marked them down to just $18m each.

By then, this tiny part of the secondhand airliner market was becoming flooded with this type of four-engined aircraft, which had been made uneconomic by high fuel prices. This, and the deteriorating state of the grounded planes, pushed their value steadily lower. By 2012, after three years sitting unused and un-serviced in the humid atmosphere of Athens, the only offer was from Apollo Aviation in Miami, which wanted the planes for scrap. The Greek trade unions kicked up a fuss about state assets being flogged cheaply abroad. But the deal was eventually sealed by the new government earlier this month, with the planes being sold for just $10m each.

So, a sale of surplus state assets that might have strengthened Greece’s coffers by $180m in 2009 ends up raising just $40m, three years and two international bail-outs later. In part the most recent slump in value is because the buyer will have to spend up to $20m on repairs to make the planes fit enough to be ferried across the Atlantic with no passengers (which is cheaper than full restoration). At these prices it might have even been better to break them up for scrap in Athens: at least that would have provided a bit of work for jobless Greeks.

from the Economist

Yiannis Stournaras was sworn-in on July 5th; four days later he put his signature for the sale of the four Airbus putting an end to the comic-tragedy that could have forced Greece to pay money to some scrap dealer in order to get rid of them – at the very end.