Construction of three motorways in Greece cost 1.2 billion euros more than it should. Furthermore the projects were poorly planned and significantly delayed, a report by the European Court of Auditors on public-private partnerships (PPPs) has found. The EU Auditors examined construction projects in four EU member states, that is France, Ireland, Greece and Spain in an audit that took place between May 2016 and September 2017.
- the E65 Central Greece Motorway cost 20.2 million euros per kilometer
- the national road from Elefsina to Patra cost 13 million euros/km
- the highway from Corinth to Kalamata and its offshoot from Lefktro to Sparti cost 8.7 million euros/km.
- The Greek ‘reset’: What happens when things go wrong in a PPP and who pays the bill? Close to 1.2 billion additional euro paid by the public.
The report stated that in the funding period from 2000 to 2014 eight PPPs were subsidized by the European Union at a total cost of 6.8 billion euros.
Greece received the highest subsidy rate in the bloc for these projects, amounting to 58.5 percent or 3.3 billion euros. Notably, the country with the highest number of PPPs, (France, with 21 projects) spent 9.8 billion euros and only received 324 million euros in funding from Brussels.
The report concludes that new PPPs should not be encouraged in cases where problems remain unsolved.
Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) harness both the public and the private sector to provide goods and services conventionally supplied by the public sector, while easing the tight budget constraints on public spending. We found that despite PPPs have the potential to achieve faster policy implementation and ensure good maintenance standards, the audited projects were not always effectively managed and did not provide adequate value for money.
Potential benefits of PPPs were often not achieved, as they suffered delays, cost increases and were under-used, and resulted in 1.5 billion euro ineffective spending, out of which 0.4 billion euro EU funds.
This was also due to the lack of adequate analyses, strategic approaches towards the use of PPPs and institutional and legal frameworks.
With only few Member States having consolidated experience and expertise in implementing successful PPP projects, there is a high risk that PPPs will not contribute to the expected extent to the aim to implement greater part of EU funds through blended projects including PPPs.
The full report in pdf is here
The report is no surprise. It was never a secret that Greeks pay each square meter of a highway in gold and several media in the before the economic crisis past had criticized such practices.